AITA for Refusing to Get Rid of My Dog for My Pregnant Sister? The Internet Has Thoughts

My sister is pregnant, and while I’m excited to be an aunt, I never expected her to demand I make a huge sacrifice for her baby. She wants me to get rid of my dog because she claims she’s suddenly allergic. When I refused, family drama exploded. Am I the jerk here?

The Unexpected Ultimatum

I’ve had my dog, Milo, for five years. He’s my best friend, and I can’t imagine life without him. When my sister announced her pregnancy, I was thrilled for her. But then she dropped a bombshell: she wanted me to rehome Milo because she claimed her pregnancy had triggered severe allergies.

At first, I thought she was joking. I don’t even live with her, so how is my dog affecting her? But she insisted that whenever she visits, she gets itchy eyes and starts sneezing. Her solution? Either I give up Milo or she won’t come over anymore.

I told her she was free to avoid my house if Milo bothered her, but I wasn’t going to give him up. That’s when the guilt-tripping began. My parents said I was being selfish and that “family comes before pets.” But to me, Milo is family.

Internet Reactions: Who’s in the Wrong?

Defending OP:

• “You don’t live together. Her allergy isn’t your responsibility.”
• “If she’s really allergic, she can take precautions instead of forcing you to give up your pet.”

Defending the Sister:

• “Pregnancy can cause severe allergies—she’s not making it up.”
• “Family comes first. If she can’t be around your dog, shouldn’t you at least consider her health?”

Some readers pointed out that pregnancy hormones can cause temporary allergies, meaning this might not even be a lifelong issue. Others suggested OP keep Milo in a separate room when her sister visits to find a compromise.

Standing Up for My Boundaries

I love my sister, but I don’t think it’s fair to demand I give up a pet I’ve had for years. If she’s really allergic, I’ll happily meet her elsewhere. But making me choose between her and my dog? That’s where I draw the line.

So, Am I the Jerk?

Should I be more understanding, or is my sister asking too much? Have you ever had to choose between family and a pet? Share your thoughts!

Takeaways:
This debate highlights the challenges of balancing family requests with personal boundaries. Whether you’re on Team Dog or Team Family, it’s a reminder that compromise and respect go both ways.

Read more stories like this here