Did I Overreact? My Mother-in-Law Announced My Baby’s Name Before I Did!

Naming our baby was a deeply personal decision for my husband (32M) and me (30F). We spent months carefully choosing the perfect name, keeping it a surprise until our little one arrived. I wanted the moment to be special-just us, announced my baby’s name name to friends and family when we were ready.

But my mother-in-law (MIL) had other plans.

While I was still recovering in the hospital, she took it upon herself to share our baby’s name on social media. I hadn’t even had the chance to post about it myself. I only found out when I checked my phone and saw her post blowing up with congratulations.

The Confrontation: “You’re Overreacting”

I was livid. This was supposed to be our moment, and she completely took it away from us. I immediately called her and asked why she did it. She laughed and said, “I was just too excited! I didn’t think it was a big deal.”

I told her it was a big deal and that it felt like she had stolen something important from me. Her response? “You’re overreacting. It’s just a name, and everyone was going to find out anyway.”

My husband was caught in the middle, trying to calm both of us down. He agreed it wasn’t right for her to post before we did, but he also felt I was making too much of a fuss over it.

Different Perspectives: Overreaction or Justified Response?

Supporting My Reaction: “That Was Completely Out of Line”

Many people agreed that I had every right to be upset:

“Announcing a baby’s name is a special moment for the parents. She had no right to take that away from you.”

“She knew what she was doing. If she was that excited, she could’ve waited a few hours.”

“It’s not just about the name – it’s about boundaries and respect.”

Defending My MIL: “She Was Just Excited”

Some people thought I was taking it too personally:

“She didn’t mean any harm. She was just happy and wanted to share the joy.”

“The name would have been announced eventually – does it really matter who said it first?”

“It’s annoying, sure, but is it really worth this much drama?”

Final Thoughts: So…Did I Overreact?

I still feel like something special was taken from me, and my MIL’s lack of apology only made it worse. But maybe I let my emotions take over too much.

What do you think – did I overreact, or was my frustration valid? Let’s discuss!

Read more stories like this here