AITA for Refusing to Let My Sister Bring Her Dog to My Wedding?
Weddings are supposed to be about love and celebration, but somehow, mine has turned into a family feud over a dog. My sister is furious that I won’t let her bring her Dog to My Wedding, and now I’m wondering if I’m the unreasonable one.
Why I Said No to the Dog to My Wedding
My fiancé and I have spent over a year planning our dream wedding. We found the perfect venue—an elegant indoor hall with a beautiful outdoor garden for photos. The one rule the venue has? No pets, except for service animals.
My sister, Emily, has a golden retriever named Bailey, and she treats him like her child. I love Bailey too, but I never expected him to be part of my wedding day. When Emily asked if she could bring him, I explained that the venue doesn’t allow pets. I assumed that would be the end of it. It wasn’t.
The Drama Begins
Emily kept pushing the issue, saying Bailey is well-behaved and wouldn’t cause any problems. She even suggested we sneak him in or keep him outside in the garden area. I told her I wasn’t comfortable bending the rules, and I didn’t want to stress about a dog on my wedding day. That’s when things escalated.
She accused me of being heartless and said if I “really cared about family,” I’d make an exception. When I stood my ground, she stormed off and later sent a long text saying I was making her choose between me and Bailey. She even hinted that she might not come to the wedding at all if her “baby” isn’t welcome.
The Fallout
Now, my parents are involved. They think I should just let it go to keep the peace. My mom keeps saying, “It’s just a dog, what’s the big deal?” But to me, this is about boundaries. It’s my wedding, and I feel like I should get to decide what happens at it.
Some of my friends agree with me, saying Emily is being unreasonable. Others think I should just let Bailey come, since it’s “not worth the fight.” Now, I’m stuck feeling like the bad guy on my own wedding day.
The Community’s Verdict
“She’s making the wedding about her dog instead of her sister.”
“If she really wanted to be there, she wouldn’t make this an issue.”
“The venue has rules. It’s not that hard to understand.”
“If you let her bring the dog, someone else will want to break another rule.”
“A wedding isn’t the place for a pet, no matter how much you love them.”
“She can survive a few hours without her dog.”
“This isn’t about the dog it’s about control.”
Final Thoughts: Am I Being Too Harsh?
I love my sister, but I also think a wedding isn’t the place for a dog especially when the venue has rules against it. Still, I don’t want this to turn into a permanent rift between us. Maybe I could have handled the conversation better, but I also feel like Emily is overreacting.
What do you think? Am I wrong for refusing to let my sister bring her dog, or is she making a big deal out of nothing? Let me know in the comments!
Read more stories like this here
