AITAH for Kicking My Best Friend Out After She Announced Her Pregnancy at My Engagement Party?

When celebrations are hijacked by unexpected announcements, emotions can run high. In today’s AITAH scenario, a bride-to-be finds herself at odds with her best friend after what was supposed to be a joyful engagement party takes an awkward turn.

Was she right to ask her friend to leave—or did she overreact?

The Story: From Champagne to Chaos

A 28-year-old woman—let’s call her Sara—shared her experience on r/AITAH. After months of planning her dream engagement party, Sara was finally celebrating her big moment with close friends and family. Everything was going perfectly: food, music, decorations, laughter.

Until her best friend, Nadia, stood up to make a toast—and dropped the bombshell.

“I just wanted to share some special news too,” Nadia said, beaming. “I’m pregnant!”

The room erupted in gasps and congratulations. But Sara stood frozen.

The Problem: Timing Is Everything

Nadia had been Sara’s best friend since college. They’d been through everything together. So why did this feel like a betrayal?

Sara said she smiled politely in the moment, but inside, she was seething. What was supposed to be her night had just become Nadia’s.

Later in the evening, she pulled Nadia aside and asked her to leave the party early.

“I love you, but this was supposed to be about me and [my fiancé],” Sara told her. “You had no right to make it about you.”

Nadia was shocked. She accused Sara of being petty and jealous, and left in tears. Since the party, several mutual friends have taken Nadia’s side, saying pregnancy is joyous news and Sara should’ve just let her have the moment.

Sara turned to Reddit with a heavy heart: AITAH for asking her to leave?

The Debate: When Good News Comes at a Bad Time

Sara’s Side: Respect the Moment

Weddings and engagement parties are once-in-a-lifetime milestones. And for many people, they’re the only times when the spotlight is truly on them.

Sara felt that Nadia used her platform to steal attention, knowingly or not. And Reddit largely agreed.

“Big announcements at someone else’s event are a major faux pas,” one top comment read. “Even good news can be bad manners if the timing is wrong.”

Another wrote: “Nadia could have told people privately the next day. She hijacked the moment, and that’s not okay.”

This wasn’t about being unsupportive—it was about feeling overshadowed during a milestone that Sara had planned and anticipated for months.

Nadia’s Side: Sharing Joy Isn’t a Crime

On the other hand, some Redditors sympathized with Nadia.

“She was probably excited and wanted to share with people who matter most,” one user commented. “She didn’t mean harm—she just chose the wrong moment.”

Others argued that Sara’s reaction might have been disproportionate. Was asking her friend to leave really necessary?

Pregnancy is an emotional journey. For all we know, Nadia might have shared her news impulsively, without realizing how it might impact the event.

Party Etiquette: The Unwritten Rules

This scenario isn’t uncommon. Here are some common “event etiquette” guidelines that many agree on:

• Don’t propose at someone else’s wedding.

• Don’t announce pregnancies at someone else’s celebration.

• Always ask the host before making any big announcements.

Why? Because it’s about honoring the moment and the person it belongs to.

Even happy news can cast a shadow if delivered at the wrong time.

What Should Have Happened Instead?

For Nadia:

• She could have waited a few days and shared her pregnancy in a dedicated post or private conversation.

• If she really wanted to tell people in person, she could’ve spoken with Sara beforehand.

For Sara:

• It’s okay to be upset. But asking someone to leave might have escalated things unnecessarily.

• A private conversation after the event might have preserved the friendship.

Compatibility Check: Are These Two Friends Still on the Same Page?

Events like this don’t just cause drama—they reveal deeper issues. Was this an isolated mistake by Nadia, or part of a pattern?

Friendships evolve, and sometimes values don’t align anymore. If Nadia often crosses boundaries or makes moments about herself, Sara’s frustration might have deeper roots.

But if this was a one-time misstep, and their friendship is otherwise strong, it might be worth salvaging.

Final Verdict: Not the Villain—But Could Have Handled It Better

Most readers agree: Sara wasn’t the villain for feeling hurt or for expecting the night to be hers. Nadia’s announcement was poorly timed and insensitive, even if unintentional.

That said, asking her to leave mid-party may have worsened things. In the end, this story reminds us of the delicate balance between setting boundaries and maintaining relationships.