AITAH for Not Paying for My Brother’s Honeymoon After Skipping His Wedding?

Weddings can bring out the best—and the worst—in family dynamics. In today’s AITAH situation, one Redditor is grappling with guilt, judgment, and a financial request that has sparked serious drama. The question is simple, but the story? Anything but.

Let’s dive into what really happened.

The Background: A Family Wedding Missed

The original poster (we’ll call her Lina), 31, shared that she didn’t attend her younger brother’s wedding last month. She and her brother, Jake, have always had a rocky relationship. According to Lina, Jake has a long history of dismissive behavior, rude comments, and what she describes as “selective involvement” with family members—only reaching out when he needs something.

When Jake got engaged, Lina wasn’t asked to be part of the wedding party. In fact, she wasn’t even invited until a month before the wedding, and only received an emailed invitation—not a formal card like the rest of the family.

Feeling like an afterthought, Lina made a choice: she didn’t go.

She sent her regrets, included a polite note, and moved on.

The Twist: A Bold Ask After the Fact

Fast forward two weeks after the wedding. Jake called Lina—not to ask how she was doing or why she missed the ceremony, but to ask for money.

Specifically, he asked her to help pay for his honeymoon.

His reasoning? “Since you didn’t come to the wedding and didn’t give a gift, it’s only fair.”

Lina was stunned. She told Jake that she didn’t feel comfortable giving him money, especially after feeling so excluded from the celebration. Jake exploded, accusing her of being selfish and holding a grudge.

Now, the family is involved. Their mother thinks Lina should have attended “for the sake of family,” and is urging her to send some money just to keep the peace.

But Lina isn’t so sure.

The Internet Reacts: Was Lina in the Wrong?

Reddit’s r/AITAH community didn’t hold back—and the majority sided with Lina.

Why Most Agree Lina Is Not the Villain

• Respect Is a Two-Way Street: Jake barely included her in the wedding. Expecting financial help afterward feels entitled.

• No Obligation: Gifts are voluntary, not mandatory. Especially when someone wasn’t genuinely invited or included.

• Emotional Boundaries: Just because someone is family doesn’t mean you owe them money or support, particularly if they’ve treated you poorly in the past.

One commenter summed it up perfectly:
“He made you an afterthought, and now he wants you to bankroll his vacation? Absolutely not.”

But Not Everyone Agreed…

Some Redditors offered a more nuanced perspective.

• Family Reconciliation: A few suggested Lina could view this as a chance to rebuild the relationship.

• Cultural Expectations: In some families, attending weddings—and giving gifts—is deeply ingrained as a duty.

• The Missing Gift Debate: While many agreed Lina had no obligation, some felt that if she truly had no ill intent, a small gesture might’ve helped prevent the rift.

Still, even those who felt Lina could have handled things differently agreed that Jake’s demand came across as manipulative and transactional.

The Bigger Picture: Guilt vs. Generosity

This AITAH post highlights a common dilemma in adult family relationships: when does generosity cross into obligation?

In many families, emotional guilt is used as currency. Skipping an event? That’ll cost you a favor. Setting a boundary? That’ll come with shame.

Lina isn’t alone in feeling pressured to make up for things with money or submission. But healthy family dynamics shouldn’t come with a price tag.

What Could Have Been Done Differently?

For Jake:

• Extend a proper, timely invitation to show genuine inclusion.

• Reach out to discuss concerns before asking for money.

• Understand that gifts are given, not owed.

For Lina:

• If skipping the wedding was intended as a quiet protest, a more open conversation might’ve prevented tension.

• A card or small gesture—without money—could have softened the blow without compromising her values.

But in the end, Lina made a boundary-based decision—and sticking to it doesn’t make her the villain.

Final Verdict: Not the Villain

Setting financial or emotional boundaries doesn’t make you heartless—it makes you honest. Lina’s choice not to attend a wedding she was barely invited to was her right. Jake’s expectation that she financially compensate him afterward wasn’t just unreasonable—it was manipulative.

You don’t owe anyone money, especially not someone who only reaches out when they want something.