AITA for Confronting My Mother-in-Law About Overstepping Boundaries with My Kids?
The Situation That Sparked It All
So here’s the deal—my mother-in-law (MIL) is the definition of “involved grandma,” which is usually great. But lately, she’s been taking things a step too far. My partner and I have set clear rules for our kids when it comes to screen time, bedtime, and even the types of snacks they can have. Pretty standard stuff, right?
Well, MIL doesn’t seem to think these rules apply to her. Every time she babysits, she lets the kids stay up way past bedtime, fills them up with sugary snacks, and even allows them to watch shows we’ve explicitly banned. It’s frustrating because it undoes all the structure we’ve worked hard to build.
The Final Straw
Last weekend, MIL offered to watch the kids while we went out for dinner—a rare and much-needed break. When we returned home, it was chaos. The kids were bouncing off the walls, chocolate-stained faces grinning like they’d hit the jackpot. Turns out, MIL had not only ignored the bedtime routine but also let them watch hours of questionable YouTube content.
I’d had enough. Calmly but firmly, I told MIL that she couldn’t keep disregarding our parenting choices. Her response? She got defensive and accused me of being too controlling. According to her, “Grandmas are supposed to spoil the grandkids.” But there’s a difference between spoiling and completely undermining parents.
The Aftermath
Since the confrontation, things have been tense. My partner is stuck in the middle, trying to keep the peace, while MIL is clearly giving me the cold shoulder. She’s even told other family members that I’m “just too strict” and that she’s “only trying to help.”
Community Reactions
Comment 1: NTA. You’re the parent, and your rules matter. MIL might mean well, but she needs to respect your boundaries.
Comment 2: ESH. Your MIL overstepped, sure. But maybe you could’ve handled it more diplomatically? Grandparents often just want to create happy memories.
Comment 3: I’ve been there—it’s exhausting when someone constantly undermines your parenting. Stay firm but maybe find a compromise, like special “grandma days” with different rules.
Lessons Learned
Boundaries are essential, even with family. While I understand MIL’s desire to be the “fun grandma,” there’s a line between being fun and being disrespectful. We’re working on finding middle ground—maybe allowing a bit more leeway on special occasions, as long as it’s agreed upon in advance.
Final Thoughts
Setting boundaries isn’t about being mean; it’s about creating a stable environment for your kids. So, AITA for standing my ground? Or should I just let grandma have free rein? I’d love to hear what you think.
Read more Relationship stories here
